Supervisors address 'half-truths,' revenue confusion after referendum defeat

The gap regarding Floyd County’s possible yield stemmed from different formulas: county officials based their projection on tourist-driven retail sales, while state groups factored in all local retail sales as well as use taxes on out-of-state and online deliveries.

Supervisors address 'half-truths,' revenue confusion after referendum defeat
Floyd County Board of Supervisors Chairman Joe Turman (second from left) discusses some of the 'half-truths' that were spread about the proposed referendum to benefit Floyd County Public Schools through a sales tax increase. The referendum was voted down in the Nov. 3 election. Screen capture by Abby Whitt

At this week’s Floyd County Board of Supervisors meeting, Board members and county staff addressed misinformation regarding the proposed sales tax referendum that would benefit capital projects in Floyd County Public Schools. 

The referendum, which was on the Nov. 3 ballot for 48 Virginia localities, was voted down in Floyd by about 1,100 votes; 4,316 (57.3%) Floyd County voters cast their ballots against the up to 1% sales tax increase, and 3,210 (about 42.7%) voted in favor of it.

The General Assembly passed legislation as part of the state’s 2026 budget, allowing localities to add the referendum to local ballots.

Part of the misinformation addressed Nov. 17 revolves around a comment made about how the County would use the generated funds had the referendum passed. 

Advertisement
CTA Image

The Floyd Country Store, home of the famous Friday Night Jamboree! Featuring a wide variety of locally sourced crafts and merchandise, stop in and browse. Enjoy lunch or a sweet treat from our Café or Soda Fountain while you're there. Live music 5 days a week!

Learn more

Board Chairman Joe Turman (Burks Fork) said he was still feeling “burnt up” after reading a post online alleging that “whenever we give [the] schools money, we go somewhere else [in the schools’ budget] and cut it out.” 

“We don’t actually do that,” he said. “They can’t prove anywhere that that’s the case. When we gave them that $300,000 per year, we didn’t go somewhere else and cut out $300,000.” 

County Administrator Kim Chiddo said that in that situation “$300,000 came back in [to the general fund] because we no longer had debt service that was designated to them.”

Turman said when half-truths are “put out there, it fires up the county.” He and Chiddo emphasized that any money generated by the proposed sales tax increase had to benefit school projects under Virginia Code. 

Chiddo said that, had the referendum passed, the funding had to be placed on a designated line in the budget strictly for capital improvements — “construction, debt service, roads… something of that nature,” she said. 

Turman said county residents “just did not understand what that money was for.” He added that the lack of education regarding the referendum falls on the County “just as much as it does on anyone else.”

Supervisor Levi Cox (Locust Grove) noted that while not many of the counties that had the sales tax increase on the ballot passed it, Radford did. “... If I go to Radford, and I purchase something in Radford, I’m helping them create revenue for their schools… I think it would have been good for the county,” he said. 

ADVERTISEMENT
CTA Image

Strong bodies build strong lives. At Floyd Fitness, we create a space where movement transforms confidence, health, and energy. Whether you’re starting fresh or chasing new goals, our team and community are here to support you every step. Join today and see what strength feels like!

More about Memberships

Another part of local conversations regarding the referendum revolves around a discrepancy of estimated amounts the increase would yield. It is relevant to note there was no verbatim language prescribed for the ballot question that localities must have used, according to the Municipal League.


The Floyd County ballot question: 

Should the County of Floyd, Virginia, be authorized to levy a general retail sales tax at a rate not to exceed one percent (1%), with the revenues to be used solely for capital projects for new construction or major renovation of schools serving the County of Floyd, Virginia, including related bond and loan financing costs, and with the tax expiring on June 30, 2046?


Floyd County staff estimated about $45,000 would be generated for capital projects in the first year, while state organizations (including the Virginia Municipal League, Virginia Association of Counties, and the Virginia Department of Taxation) estimated an up to 1% increase would yield about $1.6 million for Floyd County Public Schools initially.

Cardinal News reported that throughout the next three years, the tax, if it had been approved by all localities voting on it, could raise $1.3 billion for new construction at public schools throughout the Commonwealth.

The gap regarding Floyd County’s possible yield stemmed from different formulas: county officials based their projection on tourist-driven retail sales, while state groups factored in all local retail sales as well as use taxes on out-of-state and online deliveries.

Advertisement
CTA Image

We offer locally sourced, insect and rot resistant hemlock, and lots of other species for just about any project.

We also can provide firewood, kindling, mulch, sawdust, and shavings.

Inside we produce paneling and flooring in various, often rustic local woods.

Come by or call Stacy

276-692-8754

Learn more

Supervisor Walter Phillips (Indian Valley) said some community members thought that the County would be pocketing the rest of the larger estimate and only putting about $45,000 in the fund for the schools, but that would not be allowed.

Supervisors Jerry Boothe (Courthouse District) and Cox specified that the increase in Floyd would not have been applied to food (groceries), lodging, medicine, and other essential items. 

According to county officials, the Floyd County estimate was derived from visitor impact data from local retail sales provided by the Virginia Tourism Corporation, and the up to 1% increase would have only applied to items that qualify for a general sales tax. 

However, the Municipal League said that since the Code section addresses both sales and use tax, both are included “regardless of the verbiage used.” They said use tax not being factored into the local estimate is the reason for the discrepancy between state organizations and Floyd County. 

“The only items exempted from [this] particular tax are groceries and personal hygiene items,” Josette Bulova of the Municipal League clarified. “This tax applies to all else [and] cannot be systematically applied to specific items.”

ADVERTISEMENT
CTA Image

Andrew Blevins
210 N Locust Street
Floyd, VA 24091-2105
(540) 745-2777

Next to School House Fabrics on Route 8 in the Town of Floyd.

Get a Quote